
Reactions
Lyrics
Subject matter jurisdiction is the courts power and authority to render a binding judgment on the claim presented. Federal courts are courts of limited jurisdiction and possess only the power authorized by the U.S. Constitution and federal statutes. Article III, Section I of the United State Constitution is the storehouse of power, and it tells us that inferior courts (state courts) may only exercise the power that Congress allows them (through statutes). Congress has extended the power to inferior courts in Article III, Section 2 by allowing these courts to hear nine types of cases. However, in Title 28 of the U.S. Code which contains statutes that extend the power allowing court’s jurisdiction over four types of cases: (1) federal question jurisdiction cases pursuant to 28 USC 1331, (2) diversity jurisdiction cases pursuant to 28 USC 1332, (3) supplemental cases, and (4) removal jurisdiction cases. Under 28 USC 1331, federal district courts possess jurisdiction over all civil actions “arising under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States.” It is important that the federal question appears in the plaintiff’s initial complaint conforming to the well-pleaded complaint rule, one that limits itself to a statement of its own cause of action (Mottley). Under this rule, the federal question must appear affirmatively on the face of the plaintiff’s well-pleaded complaint as part of the plaintiff’s own statement of the cause of action. A plaintiff cannot establish federal question jurisdiction by anticipating a federal defense, even if that defense is certain to arise. Similarly, a federal counterclaim asserted by a defendant does not satisfy federal question jurisdiction over a complaint that lacks an independent federal basis (Holmes). Justice Holmes created the “creation test” to determine whether the well-pleaded complaint rule is met; if the cause of action arises under federal law, then by nature it is sufficient to invoke federal question jurisdiction (American Well Works). Once the well-pleaded complaint rule is satisfied, courts evaluate whether the cause of action arises under federal law using Justice Holme’s Creation Test. Under the creation test, a suit arises under the law that creates the cause of action. If federal law creates the plaintiff’s enforceable legal right against the defendant, § 1331 is satisfied. If state law creates the cause of action, federal question jurisdiction is not satisfied. Here, there is/is not a federal question stated in the plaintiff’s initial complaint that satisfies the well-pleaded complaint rule because (blank) is/is not a substantial federal issue. Under 28 USC 1332, the diversity jurisdiction statute, district courts have original jurisdiction over all civil actions when there is (1) complete diversity of citizenship between the two parties, and (2) the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000, exclusive of interests and costs. Under the Complete Diversity Rule, no plaintiff can share state citizenship with any defendant (Strawbridge) and complete diversity must exist at the time the complaint is filed in court. Individual domicile: When the party is an individual, citizenship is determined by domicile, which requires physical presence in a state and the intent to remain there indefinitely (Mas). Corporation domicile:
Comments 0
Comments pin to the moment you're hearingPlay the song to pin your comment to a moment
Loading comments…
Made with remixy.ai
